Urban and Environmental Policy Program
AMERICAN
POLITICS AND PUBLIC POLICY
POLITICS 101
FALL 2003
Class Sessions: Tuesday and Thursday 1:30-2:55 pm (Johnson
308)
Films: Monday 7-9 pm (Weingart 117)
Professor Peter Dreier
Office: Urban & Environmental Policy Institute (UEPI)
Office Hours: Tuesday and
Thursday, 3-5 pm and by
appointment.
Phone: (323) 259-2913
Email: dreier@oxy.edu
What This Course is About
Many Americans have become cynical about politics and government. They
associate these words with election campaigns, personalities, broken promises,
scandals, or wars. Many people are now describing the current recall election
in California as a “circus.”
But politics and government are about much more than that. They shape
how we live. Almost every aspect of your life is in some way shaped by the
outcome of politics and government, which is public policy. These include:
Where you live, what you learn (or don't learn) in school, the kind of car you
drive, your career ambitions, the kind of job(s) you take, the quality of the
food you eat, and the air you breathe.
Politics and government can be a force for good or evil, for justice or
injustice. Politics and government can be competent or incompetent. This
course looks at the major institutions and ideas of American government, how
policy is made, and what impact it has on society.
This course is intended to help you understand the workings of American
government, to evaluate its strengths and weaknesses, and to help you decide
how to participate in making government work better.
Government policies are made up of a series of decisions or choices
over a period of time. These choices involve (a) whether to do anything at all
about a problem or issue and (b) what to do. These choices involve actions
such as spending money, passing laws, creating regulations, enforcing (or not
enforcing) laws and regulations, and adjudicating disputes.
All public policy involves values --
what people think is good or bad, the proper role of government, and
how society should be organized. Public policy involves political conflict
-- differences between organized
groups about what should and shouldn't be in the law and regulations.
A key to understanding American government, politics, and public policy
is to compare our own political institutions to those of other countries,
including other democracies. For
example:
o
How does voting turnout in the U.S. compare with that in other countries?
o
How do tax rates in the U.S. compare with tax rates elsewhere?
o
Is the level of poverty in the U.S. higher or lower than in other countries?
Why?
o
How does the relationship between the press and the government in the U.S.
compare with the relationship in other democracies?
o
What is the responsibility of the American government to promote and protect
human rights, American business, the environment and public health in the U.S.
and around the world?
This course is organized around three key themes:
Part 1: Democracy.
This focuses on the major
political views (sometimes called ideologies) about the appropriate role of
government and citizenship in American society. How much of a voice should
“ordinary” people have in their government - and other institutions?
We will explore the different views of the “founding fathers” and
how these views have evolved since then. We will also look at different views
about what kinds of “rights” people have or assume they have and the ways
that government protects and/or
violates these “rights.”
Part 2: Social
Class and Social Justice. This focuses on the various forms of economic and
social inequality in our society -- socio-economic classes, race and
ethnicity, and gender and sexuality. We will look at how these inequalities
shape our political system and on the ways that government and politics
promotes or discourages equality, fairness, and opportunity for people.. We
will also examine the relationship
between the private sector (business and the labor market), the public sector
(government), and individual citizens.
Part 3: Political Participation: Organized People and
Organized Money. This
focuses on the different ways that citizens, individually and as part of
groups, take part in their government. We will examine the impact of the mass
media, interest groups and their various resources, voting and campaigns,
political parties, electoral systems, Congress, the Presidency, and protest
movements. We will look at the role that money plays in influencing politics
and government. We will also look at how organized citizens can influence
politics and government through interest groups and grassroots movements.
Course Format and Requirements
The course will meet twice a week -- on Tuesdays and Thursdays
from 1:30 ‑2:55 p.m.
Every student is expected to attend every lecture and to
arrive promptly at 1:30 p. m.
Films will be shown on most Mondays at 7 p.m. in Weingart 117. These
are required. Check the last page of the syllabus for names and dates
of films.
The basic elements of this course include:
1. Reading. Readings (books, articles, reports, tables
and charts) will be assigned for each week, as specified below. Students are
expected to do the reading before the Tuesday lecture and be prepared to
discuss the readings at both class meetings. All readings (except the
books -- The Democratic Debate, Savage Inequalities, and Who
Rules America? -- will be available on electronic reserve on the
Oxy library website. Look for the website for Politics 101.
I strongly recommend that you print out all of the articles, bring them
with you to class, and keep them in a loose-leaf binder. This will help you
prepare for class discussions, papers, and exams.
2. Films. During the semester, we will show a number
of films. I expect every student to see each film. These films will be shown
on Mondays at 7 pm. (in Weingart 117). The names and dates of the films are
listed at the end of this syllabus.
3. Class Discussion. Discussion sections will center
on the readings, lectures, and films. Many of these sessions will involve
discussions about public policy issues. Students are encouraged to debate
these and disagree -- but to do so based on information and evidence as well
as their own values.
4. Writing. Each student will have a minimum of six
writing assignments during the term ‑‑ four short essays (or other
assignments) based on readings, a midterm exam, and a final exam. In grading
your written work, we will look not only at the content, but also at
the style. Be sure to proofread your papers before handing them
in. Look for spelling, punctuation, and grammatical errors. Be clear and
concise. Don't repeat yourself. Cite your sources. Make sure you understand
the assignment. It helps to do an outline before you begin writing. Show it to
your discussion section professor and discuss it with him/her before revising.
Students are also urged to take advantage of the college's Center for Teaching
and Learning (ground floor of the library) to get help with their essays.
Don't be hesitant. The Center staff is eager to assist you and can help you
improve your writing significantly. For most essays and both exams the
following eight criteria will be used:
1. Do you have a clear
thesis? This should be a sentence or two early in your essay.
2. Have you employed appropriate concepts?
3.
Have you presented persuasive evidence to support your thesis or arguments?
4.
Have you made appropriate reference to the assigned readings?
5.
Have you made a tie‑in to current events? Refer to items in the daily
newspapers when appropriate.
6.
Have you sought to find a creative twist ‑‑ a different viewpoint,
a distinctive argument, unusual
evidence?
7.
Is your prose readable? Read your prose aloud to check on this.
8.
Is your essay mechanically flawless? Typos, misspellings, and punctuation
errors are inexcusable.
5. Newspapers Clippings
I encourage students in Politics 101 to get in the habit of reading
a daily newspaper. The most useful papers are the New York Times,
the Los Angeles Times, the Christian Science Monitor, and the Wall
Street Journal. You can get a subscription to any of these publications,
buy some of them in the bookstore, or read them in the library. You can also
subscribe to the Washington Post National Weekly, which includes the
best articles from the previous week's Washington Post. You can
subscribe via the web.
Our library also subscribes to many "opinion magazines."
These are weekly publications that look at politics and policy from a
particular perspective -- conservative, moderate, liberal, progressive,
libertarian, religious, feminist, environmental, etc. Among the more
interesting are the Nation, American Prospect, Weekly
Standard, New Republic, In These Times, Commonweal,
and National Review.
In an effort to help students develop the newspaper habit (which
includes articles, commentaries and editorials on government, politics and
public policy), you are asked to submit at the beginning of each Thursday
section meeting a timely item from a daily newspaper which is directly
applicable to one of the issues addressed in the Politics 101 readings for
that week. Each week, attach a few notes that explain why you have chosen
this article -- how it is relevant for the topics covered in class that week.
These notes must involve no more than 100 words.
A minimum of ten clippings is required during our 13 week
semester, but it is strongly suggested that you submit one each Thursday. (No make‑ups will be permitted.)
Make sure you put your name on the clipping and that the name and
date of the newspaper is identified.
On Thursdays, I will ask at least one student (selected randomly) to
present very briefly to the group his/her clipping and its significance.
This presentation should be no more than two or three minutes
describing how the article, editorial or opinion piece illustrates and/or
amplifies some aspect of that week's topic.
Grades
Your grades will be based on four factors:
25%
on attendance and participation in class sessions and films, and your
performance on the weekly news clipping assignments.
25% on the four written assignments.
25% on a mid-term examination.
25% on a final examination.
Required Books to Purchase
1. Bruce Miroff,
Raymond Seidelman, and Todd Swanstrom, The Democratic Debate: An
Introduction to American Politics, Boston: Houghton Mifflin, third
edition, 2002.
2. Jonathan Kozol, Savage Inequalities: Children in
America's Schools, New York: Crown Publishers, 1991.
3. G. William
Domhoff, Who Rules America? Fourth Edition. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2002.
4. Stephen J.
Rose, Social Stratification in the United States:
The New American Profile Poster:
New Press, 2000.
Poster
The
Rose book comes with a poster called “Social Stratification in the United
States.” Please put this poster up on a wall in your room at the beginning
of the semester. Look at it occasionally. Try to figure out your reaction to
it during the semester. What is your initial reaction?. Does it change during
the semester? We’ll discuss the poster a few times during the semester.
Helpful
Materials on Library Reserve
I will place examples of very good writing assignments in a folder on
reserve in the Library for those who are interested in seeing what constitutes
good responses to the bi-weekly writing assignments.
(The names of the student authors are removed but the instructor's
comments on the essays do appear as well as the grade assigned.) It will be at
the circulation desk.
Interesting
Websites About American Politics
The internet has opened up a wide array of sources about American
politics. There are thousands of websites on every conceivable topic.
Fortunately, the University of Michigan has assembled the best of these
resources and put them on its website. It
includes such topics as upcoming elections at the federal, state, and local
levels; biographies; campaign finances; political cartoons; members of
Congress (including voting records); political consultants; a wide variety of
domestic and foreign policy issues; lobby groups; news sources and
periodicals; political advertising; political parties; the Presidency; public
opinion; think tanks; and advocacy groups. We encourage you to browse this
website at:
Project
Vote Smart (http://www.vote-smart.org)
All students should become familiar with Project Vote Smart, a
non-profit organization that provides a great deal of information about our
members of Congress, including their biographies, voting records, sources of
campaign funds, and other data. I will ask you to use this information,
available on the group’s website, throughout the semester.
Extra
Credit for Political Participation
I encourage students in Politics 101 not only to vote but also to participate
directly in the political process and to stay abreast of the campaigns and
issues through the news media.
Some students may wish to take advantage of Occidental's location in a
very active and interesting political environment.
Not all students in Politics 101 will have the time, motivation or
mobility needed to participate in this optional feature of the course.
But, as an incentive for those who wish to do so, we will give students extra
credit for participating in a political campaign or working in a political
office. Student who complete this
assignment will increase their final grade by a third of a grade – in other
words, from a C to a C+, or from an A- to an A.
There are ten weeks between the beginning of the semester and election
day -- Tuesday, November 5. We will give extra credit to students who spend a
minimum of 20 hours volunteering in one of the current campaigns or in
a political office. Here are the choices:
Campaigns for U.S. President. . The
election won’t be held until November 2004, but each candidate,
including the incumbent (President Busy) is already campaigning. You can work
for the Republican incumbent, one of the Democratic challengers, or one of the
candidates from other parties, such as the Green Party, Libertarian Party,
etc. It is too early for
most incumbent members of Congress to be gearing up their campaigns, but
candidates for President are already campaigning.
There
are no major races for LA office or state legislature this fall.
Volunteers who show enthusiasm and take initiative often stand out and
are noticed by campaign staff and candidates.
Over the years, a number of Oxy students who have volunteered in
campaigns have been offered jobs with the candidates after they are elected.
(Of course, this meant they worked for the winner!)
Political Offices: You can also volunteer to work for a current
elected official – a member of the LA City Council, a member of the
California Assembly or Senate, or a U.S. Senator of Congressperson.
To document your participation, write a three page report
describing what you did and summarizing the insights and understanding you
gained from this participation. Explain
what your responsibilities were. Discuss how this experience supplemented what
you learned in Politics 101. Did it reinforce what you learned? Did it
challenge what you learned? Include
the name and phone number of someone on the campaign staff or volunteer
coordinator who can verify your participation.
How do you go about volunteering?
First, you have to select a campaign or a police officeholder. In the
case of candidates for office, decide campaign you want to work for. You can
decide on the basis of the candidate or on the basis of the political party,
or on the basis of a particular issue (for example, does this candidate
support your views about abortion, or gun control, or funding for public
education). You can work for a
candidate from any of the political parties (Republican, Democrat, Green,
Libertarian, etc).
Once you’ve decided which campaign or office you want to work for,
call the office, offer your time and enthusiasm. Be sure to tell them
how much time you have available and what days are best for you. (A lot of
campaign work occurs on weekends and a nights).
What will you do? Volunteers perform a variety of tasks. They make
phone calls. They do office work. They attend rallies and candidates forums.
They answer the phone. They distribute literature at shopping malls and
door-to-door. The accompany the candidate to events. You’ll need to get to
and from the campaign on your own. Some campaign offices are accessible by bus
and a few (in Eagle Rock) by foot. By
the way, no prior experience is required to do campaign volunteer work.
Use the WWW to find out more information about these campaigns.
Speakers
on Campus
There will be a number of speakers on campus this semester discussing
topics related to this course. We will alert you to these events and strongly
encourage you to attend.
“West
Wing”
I
encourage students to regularly watch the TV show, “West Wing,” Wednesdays
at 9 pm.
“West
Wing” depicts the inner workings of the White House and the relationship of
the President to Congress, the court system, lobby groups, public opinion, and
other factors. Evaluate how realistic the show is by comparing it to the
readings in class and the way the Presidency is depicted in newspapers and
magazines.
Academic
Honesty
We will distribute in class a hand-out about academic honesty and
plagiarism. We take these issues very serious and so should you.
Students
with Disabilities
Accommodation of disability-related needs is available. Please let me know if you need some kind of accommodation.
Part
I: Democracy
Week
1 The Democratic Debate: Different Views About Democracy
Thursday
August 28, Tuesday Sept. 2, and Thursday Sept. 4
Topics:
What did the founders of our country mean by the term “democracy”? What
were their different views about the concept of democracy? What is the
difference between “elite” and “popular” conceptions of democracy? How
are those different views reflected in political debates and controversies
today?
Films: “Occupation” (44 min.) and “Holding Ground” (58 min.)
Miroff, Seidelman, and Swanstrom, The Democratic Debate (MSS)
Chapter 1, "Introduction: The Democratic Debate"
Declaration of Independence (MSS, Appendix, pp. A1-A3)
*Young,
"George Robert Twelves Hewes, A Patriot Shoemaker of Boston" (in The
Way We Lived)
*Zinn, "Young Ladies Who Can Picket" (from
Zinn, You Can't Be Neutral
on a Moving
Train)
*Greenhouse,
"5 Years After Workers' Vote, Appeals Stall Shipyard Union" (New
York Times, July 10, 1998) and Darce, "Avondale Ordered to Rehire
22" (New Orleans Times-Picayune, July 11, 2001)
*Appelbaum and Dreier, "The Campus Anti-Sweatshop Movement" (The
American Prospect, August/September 1999)
*Walljasper, "When Activists Win" (The Nation, March
3, 1997)
*Greenhouse,
“Battle Lines Drawn Over Ergonomic Rules” (NY Times,
Nov. 18, 2000) and “Bush Plan to Avert Work Injuries Seeks Voluntary
Steps By Industry” (NY Times, April 6, 2002)
*Cong. Bernard Sanders, "Whither American Democracy?" (LA
Times, Jan. 16, 1994)
Week
2 Is Government Necessary to Have a Good Society?
Tuesday
Sept. 9 and Thursday Sept. 11
Topics:
How did the founders of our country disagree about how to set up our
government? What were the critical issues over which they disagreed?
How much influence should ordinary citizens have in our governmental
decision-making? Is democracy about majority rule or minority protections? Is
democracy the same thing as freedom? How central is the role of private property in
American democracy? What vehicles do ordinary citizens have for getting their
views and voices heard? What are the obstacles to achieving a full democracy? To
what degree was American democracy set up to govern a society that no longer
exists? What is “federalism?”What roles are most appropriate at different
levels of government – federal, state, local?
We will use the debate over smoking – and the politics of public
health -- to illustrate these concepts.
Film: “Never Say Die” (46 min.)
America's Ambivalence About Government
MSS: Chapter 2, "The Revolution and the Constitution”
MSS: James Madison, "Federalist No. 10" (Appendix, pp.
A12-A16)
*Brownstein,
"The Government Once Scorned, Becomes Savior" (LA Times,
Sept.19, 2001)
*Seib, "The Federal System: You Can Get Away from
Washington‑‑But Not Government" (Wall Street Journal,
June 21, 1995)
*Kettl,
"Clueless in the Capital" (Washington Monthly, July/August
1999)
*Alperovitz, “Tax the Plutocrats” (The Nation, Jan. 27,
2003)
Federalism: What Level of Government Should Do What?
MSS: Chapter 15, “State and Local Politics: The Dilemma of
Federalism”
*Hansen, “The 2000 Outcome: Blame Federalism” (Washington Post,
Dec. 1, 2001)
*Lueck, "Bush Poses
Changes to Medicaid to Give States Greater Flexibility" (Wall Street
Journal, Aug 6, 2001)
*Shogren, “States, White House at Odds on Environment” (LA Times,
Dec. 29, 2002)
*Hertsgaard, “California Green Light” (The Nation, August
19/26, 2002)
*Nichols, “Local Heroes” (The Nation, June 9, 2003)
*Chait,
“Rogue State: The Case Against Delaware” (New Republic, August
19/26, 2002)
Democracy and Public Health: Case Study of the Tobacco Industry and
Smoking
*Bartecchi, MacKenzie and Schrier, “The Medical Effects of
Tobacco Consumption”
(Scientific American, May 1995)
*Chart:
“Adult Per Capita Cigarette Consumption and Major Smoking and Health
vents, United States, 1900-1999"
*Chart: “U.S. Consumption and Prices of Cigarettes, 1954-1992"
*Roberts
and Watson, “Should Cigarettes Be Outlawed?” (U.S. News, April 18,
1994)
*Ellingwood,
“Montgomery Eateries Dread Smoking Ban” (LA Times, Dec. 17, 2002)
*”High
Taxes, Get Tough Legislation Are Forcing More Canadians to Curtail or
Quit Smoking” (Seattle Times, Nov. 7, 1993)
*Wilgoren, “Facing New Costs, Some Smokers Say `Enough,’” (NY
Times, July 17,
2002)
*Broder, “Cigarette Makers in a $368 Billion Accord to Curb Lawsuits
and Curtail Marketing” (NY Times, June 21, 1997)
*”The Tobacco Settlement” (LA Times, June 21, 1997)
*McKenzie,
“Tobacco Deal: Legal Mugging by Government” (LA Times, July 15,
1997)
*Goldberg,
“Big Tobacco’s Endgame” (NY Times Magazine, June 21, 1998)
*Greenhouse,
“Justices Rein In Local Regulation of Tobacco Ads” (NY Times, June
29, 2001)
*Gronke,
“Tobacco Control Proposal Criticized” (LA Times, July 28, 2001)
*Gorman,
“Smoker Agrees to $100 Million Award” (LA Times, August 22, 2001)
*Holley, “Philip Morris Angers Czechs With Tobacco Toll Report” (LA
Times, Aug. 5, 2001)
*Girion and Levin, "RJ Reynolds Fined for Ads Aimed at Teens"
(LA Times, June 7,
2002)
*”33% Drop in Teen Smoking" (LA Times, October 5, 2001)
Week
3 What Does Government Really Do?
Tuesday,
Sept. 16 and Thursday, Sept. 18
Topics:
The relationship between individuals, business, and government. The key
functions of government: regulate
the behavior of institutions and individuals; provide services; invest in
people and institutions (businesses, industries, universities, etc) to improve
social and economic conditions; and promote public safety and national
security. To accomplish these tasks, it must also raise revenues. What is the appropriate role and size of government? Is
"big government" the problem or the solution? What are the arguments
for and against government's role? What
do we mean by "liberal," "conservative,"
"centrist," "radical" and other labels for describing
different views about what government should and should not do? How does the
United States compare with other democratic countries in terms of the role of
government? How is democracy in
the U.S. similar to and different from democracies in other nations? Did
September 11th change our views on the appropriate role and size of
government?
Film: “Trade Secrets” (120 min.)
Regulate the Behavior of Institutions and People
*Reich, "The Bridgestone Tire Controversy" (from Locked in
the Cabinet, 1997)
*Bradsher,
“Stricter Rules for Tire Safety Were Scrapped by Reagan” (NY Times,
Sept. 4, 2000)
*Mintz, "Remembering Thalidomide" (Washington Post Weekly,
July 22-28, 1996)
*Warrick,
"Is U.S. Beef Safe to Eat?" (Washington Post Weekly, April
16-22, 2001)
*Hakim,
“Auto Union and Honda Dispute Safety Record at Plants in Ohio”
(NY Times, June 26, 2002)
Invest in People and Institutions
*Broder,
"Gramm's Life of Entitlements" (Washington Post, March 6,
1995)
*David
Horsey, “Meanwhile, in Washington, D.C...” (Cartoon, Seattle
Post-Intelligencer, April 2003)
*Nazario,
"Going to School Hungry" (LA Times, November 20, 1994)
*Gorman,
"Faces of the Uninsured" (National Journal, July 17, 1999)
*Bergmann,
"Decent Child Care at Decent Wages" (American Prospect, Jan.
1-15, 2001)
*Hage, Fischer, and Black, "America's Other Welfare State" (U.S.
News & World
Report, April 10, 1995)
Provide Public Services
*Gosselin, “The 90s: Private Boom Stingy on Public Good” (LA Times,
Aug. 5, 2001)
*Isaacs and Schroeder, “Where the Public Good Prevailed” (American
Prospect, June 4, 2001)
*Cimons, "Fluoridation: A Shining Public Health Success" (LA
Times, Jan. 26, 1995)
*Toner,
"Political Battle Lines Are Clearly Drawn in Fight Over Medicare Drug
Coverage" (NY Times, July 24, 2000)
Promote Public Safety and National Security
MSS: Chapter 18, “Foreign Policy in the National Security State”
*Soros, “America’s Global Role” (American Prospect, June
2003)
*Gitlin,
“Can the Peace Movement Reinvent Itself?” (LA Times, March 23,
2003)
*Dreier and Reiman, "Prisoners of Misleading Facts," Dissent,
Spring 1996
*Fortunato,
“Corporate Crime and Voting Rights” (Dissent, Summer 2002)
*Parenti, "The Prison Industrial Complex" (Corporate Watch,
September 1999)
*Herbert, “Who Gets The Death Penalty?” (NY Times, May 13,
2002)
Is The United States Unique?
*Kingdon,
America the Unusual, 1999. (“Introduction” and “Public Policy”)
*Havemann,
"Diagnosis: Healthier in Europe" (LA Times, Dec. 30, 1992)
*Dreier and Bernard, "Kinder, Gentler Canada" (American
Prospect, Winter 1993)
*Greenhouse,
"If the French Can Do It, Why Can't We?" (NY Times Magazine,
Nov. 14, 1993)
*Williams, “So, This is Heaven: Norway” (LA Times, Nov. 8,
2001)
*Wilgoren, “Education Study Finds U.S. Falling Short” (NY Times,
June 13, 2001)
*Gornick
and Meyers, “Support for Working Families: What the U.S. Can Learn From
Europe” (American Prospect, January 1-15, 2001)
*”America: A Unique Outlook?” (American Enterprise,
March/April 1990)
*Pine, "Are Americans Overtaxed?" (LA Times, April 30,
1998)
America By the Numbers: Comparing the U.S. and Other Democracies
Percent of Total Household Wealth Controlled by the Top 1%
Share of National Income: Rich-Poor Ratio
Per Capita Income Using Market Exchange Rates, 1960-98
Index of Hourly Compensation Costs
Tax Revenues in OECD Countries, 1965-1993, as a Percent of GDP
Infant Mortality
Elderly Poverty
Child Poverty
Living in Poverty
Average Annual Exit Rate From Poverty
Union Density By Country
Voter Turnout
High School Graduation Rates
Number of Days in an Average School Year
Mean Scale Score in Mathematics and Science of Grade 8, 1995
Ratio
of Teacher Salary to GDP Per Capita (Primary and Lower Secondary)
Youth Homicide
Prisoners (Per 1,000 People)
Total
Health Expenditure as a Percentage of GDP, Per Capital Health Spending and
Percentage of Medical Expenditures covered by Public (OECD Countries)
Percentage of Population Covered By Public Health Insurance
Prescription Drug Prices in U.S. and Other Countries
Legally Mandated Paid Vacations
Average Price of a Gallon of Gas
Travel on Public Transportation as a Percent of All Travel
News as a Percent of All TV Programming
Week
4 The Courts, Civil Rights and
Civil Liberties
Tuesday
Sept. 23 and Thursday September 25
Topics:
What are civil liberties and civil rights? How have civil rights and civil
liberties been understood in the American political system? What role have the
courts, the President, Congress, and ordinary citizens played in expanding,
defending, or reducing civil rights and civil liberties? What is free speech
and what are the limits, in any, to free speech? Are group rights or
individual rights more important? How
does our criminal justice system work? Why does the US have so many people in
prison compared with other countries? Why is the US the only democratic
country that still has a death penalty? Are there trade-offs between
protecting individual liberties and promoting public safety and national
security? What lessons should we learn about these trade-offs from the events
of last September 11 and the subsequent controversy over civil liberties?
Film: “Guilty
by Suspicion” (105 min.)
MSS:
Chapter 14: The Judiciary and the Democratic Debate
Chapter 16: Civil Liberties and Civil Rights
The Court System
*Schkade and Sunstein, “Judging By Where You Sit” (NY Times,
June 11, 2003)
*Greenhouse, “Court Had Rehnquist Initials Intricately Carved on the
Docket” (NY Times, July 2, 2002)
*Taylor, "The Supreme Question" (Newsweek, July 10,
2000)
*Adler, "Irreparable Harm"(New Republic, July 30,
2001)
Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis
*King, "Is Congress Giving Too Much Surveillance Power...?
Yes" (Insight, Jan. 14,
2002)
*Smith, "Is Congress Giving Too Much Surveillance Power...?
No" (Insight, Jan. 14,
2002)
*”Limiting Civil Liberties” (LA Times, March 10, 2002)
*Bixler, "Immigrants' Rights at Risk?" (Atlanta Journal
Constitution, Feb. 27, 2002)
Freedom of Expression
*Volokh,
“The US Constitution Says We All Have to Live with Being Offended” (LA
Times, July 18, 2001)
*McCain, “Black Leaders Refuse to Pledge Allegiance to Flag” (Washington
Times,
June 22, 2001)
*Gettleman, "Confederate Flag Still Flies, as Do Lawsuits to
Shelve It" (LA Times, July 25, 2001)
Separation of Church and State
*Gettleman, “Alabama’s Top Judge Defiant on Commandments’
Display” (NY Times,
August 21, 2003)
*Savage, "School Vouchers Win Backing of High Court" (LA
Times, June 28, 2002)
*Dolan, "Pledge: Phrase `Under God’ Is Ruled Illegal" (LA
Times, June 27, 2002)
*Press, “Faith Based Furor” (NY Times Magazine, April 1,
2001)
Part
II: Social Class in America
Week
5 Is America a “Class”
Society?
Tuesday
Sept. 30 and Thursday October 2
Topics:
What are the key features of our economic system? What is the relationship
between democracy and the economy? What role, if any, should government play
in shaping how our economy works? What influence do business, consumers,
employees and other groups have in our governmental decision-making?
Film: “The Big One” (90 min).
MSS: Chapter
3, "The American Political Economy"
Domhoff, Who Rules America? (Chapter 1, Class and Power in
America; Chapter 2
The Corporate Community; and Chapter 3 The Corporate Community and the
Upper Class)
*Hofmeister,
“Idaho Town Has Much Invested in Elite Retreat” (LATimes, July 11,
2003)
*Grimsley, "....U.S. Workers Keep Going and Going" (Wash.
Post Weekly, Sept. 13,
1999)
*Bernstein, "All's Not Fair in Labor Wars" (Business Week,
July 19, 1999)
Week
6: Corporations and the Global Economy
Tuesday
October 7 (No class on Thursday, October 9 – fall break)
Films: “Zoned for Slavery” (23 min.)
and “The Global Assembly Line” (58 min.)
What is the Global Economy?
*Barnet, “Lords of the Global
Economy” (The Nation, Dec. 19, 1994)
*Birnbaum, “Where America Shops: Wal-Mart” (America@Work,
April 2001)
*Silverstein, "Millions for Viagra, Pennies for Diseases of the
Poor" (Nation, July 19, 1999)
“Good to the Last Drop” (Chronicle of Higher Education, June
6, 2003)
*Kuttner, “Double Standard” (American Prospect, June 31,
2003)
Sweatshops and Child Labor: Should We -- Can We? --
Set Rules for Business
Practices in the Global Economy?
*Hayden and Kernaghan, “Pennies
an Hour, and No Way Up” (NY Times,
July 6, 2002)
*Kristof, “Let Them Sweat” (NY
Times, June 25, 2002)
*Van Der Werf, “Labor Violations Found at Factory Used for College
Apparel” (Chronicle of Higher
Education, Feb. 9, 2001)
*Thompson, "Mexican Labor
Protest Gets Results" (NY Times, Oct. 8, 2001)
*Friedman, "Knight Is Right" (NY Times, June 20, 2000)
*Kahn, "Playing the China Card" (NY Times, July 7,
2000)
*Landler, "Making Nike Shoes in Vietnam" (NY Times,
April 28, 2000)
*Arnold, “Translating Union into Khmer” (NY Times, July 12,
2001)
*Bernstein,
"Sweatshop Reform: How to Solve the Standoff" (Business Week,
May 3, 1999)
Corporations and Democracy: How Should We Hold Corporations
Accountable?
*Stewart, “Spend! Spend! Where Did Tyco’s Money Go? (New Yorker,
Feb. 17, 2003)
*Noonan, “Capitalism Betrayed” (Wall Street Journal, June
28, 2002)
*Wilentz, “A Scandal for Our Time” (American Prospect, Feb.
25, 2002)